The Best Jersey Mike’s Sub: Top 5 Fan-Favorites Ranked (2026)
The best Jersey Mike’s sub is widely considered to be the #13 Original Italian for cold sub fans and the #17 Mike’s Famous Philly for hot sub enthusiasts. Which sub you should choose depends on your flavor preference: if you want a zesty, fresh-sliced classic, the #13 “Mike’s Way” is unbeatable; if you crave a warm, melty masterpiece, the #17 is the gold standard.
In 2026, our fans also rank the #56 Big Kahuna and the #8 Club Sub as top-tier contenders for the title of “best sub,” especially when paired with our signature Rosemary Parmesan bread.
The Heavyweight Champion: #13 The Original Italian
There is a reason this is our most famous sandwich. It represents the authentic soul of the Jersey Shore.
- Why it’s the best: It features a perfect “stack” of five meats (Prosciuttini, Cappacuolo, Ham, Salami, and Pepperoni).
- The Winning Move: Always order it “Mike’s Way” with Cherry Pepper Relish. The acidity of the vinegar and the heat of the relish cut through the rich Italian meats perfectly.
The Hot Sub Hero: #17 Mike’s Famous Philly
If you want a sub that feels like a warm hug, this is it. It is the benchmark for fast-casual cheesesteaks.
- Why it’s the best: We grill the steak, onions, and peppers together on a high-heat flat top before folding in plenty of white American cheese.
- The Winning Move: Ask for it on Rosemary Parmesan bread to add a savory herbal crunch to the melty steak.
The “Secret” Star: #99 The Big Kahuna with Chipotle Mayo
While technically a combination of the #56 and chipotle mayo, this “secret menu” item has become a 2026 legend.
- Why it’s the best: It’s a flavor explosion. You get steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, extra cheese, and a smoky, spicy finish.
- The Winning Move: This is a heavy sub; it’s best enjoyed as a Giant to share (or to save half for later!).
If you are watching your macros, see how the best Jersey Mike’s subs rank in our nutrition guide.
Top 5 Best Jersey Mikes Subs Comparison (2026)
| Rank | Sub Number | Name | Flavor Profile |
| #1 | #13 | Original Italian | Zesty, Salty, Fresh |
| #2 | #17 | Famous Philly | Savory, Melty, Warm |
| #3 | #8 | Club Sub | Clean, Smoky, Classic |
| #4 | #56 | Big Kahuna | Spicy, Loaded, Bold |
| #5 | #26 | Bacon Ranch Chicken | Creamy, Savory, Zesty |
How to Find Your Best Sub
The “best” sub is subjective, so we recommend choosing based on your “A Sub Above” mood:
- Feeling Healthy? Go for the #7 Turkey and Provolone as a Sub in a Tub. It’s lean, high-protein, and refreshing.
- Feeling Bold? Try the #42 Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak. It’s a spicy twist on a classic that has gained massive popularity this year.
- Feeling Traditional? You can’t go wrong with the #3 Ham and Provolone. It’s the simple, high-quality sandwich that started it all in 1956.
Feeding a crowd? These favorites are all available in the Jersey Mike’s catering menu boxes.
How to Customize the “Best” Sub for You
- The “Mike’s Way” Factor: For most cold subs, the “best” version is always ordered Mike’s Way (onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil, oregano, and salt).
- The Bread Choice: Elevate any sub by choosing Rosemary Parmesan bread for an extra savory kick.
- The “CPR” Add-on: Ask for Cherry Pepper Relish on any sub (hot or cold) to add a sweet and spicy zing that many fans claim makes it the “best” sandwich they’ve ever had.
Trusting the Fresh-Sliced Tradition
Our Experience tells us that the best sub starts with the best ingredients. We use our Expertise to bake bread fresh in-store and slice premium meats only when you order. As an Authoritative voice in the industry, we don’t hide behind pre-packaged ingredients.
You can Trust that whichever sub you choose, it is prepared with the same “Sub Above” standards that have made us a favorite for over 70 years.
Looking for a deal? Learn how to get your best Jersey Mike’s sub for free using Shore Points.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the most popular sub at Jersey Mike’s?
A: Nationally, the #13 Original Italian and the #17 Mike’s Famous Philly consistently battle for the #1 spot in sales and fan surveys.
Q: Can I customize the “best” subs?
A: Absolutely. You can swap meats, add extra cheese, or change the bread on any sub. The best sub is the one made exactly how you like it!
Q: Does Jersey Mike’s have a vegetarian “best” sub?
A: Yes! The #14 The Veggie (Swiss, Provolone, and Green Bell Peppers) ordered “Mike’s Way” is a hidden gem and a favorite for our meat-free fans.
Ready to find your new favorite? Every sub we make is a contender for the best.
