Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu (Hidden Items, Hacks & Custom Orders Guide)
Jersey Mike’s secret menu is a collection of “insider” sandwich builds like the #99 The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo, the meat-heavy #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak, and the legendary “Marty’s Special” that are not listed on the official board but can be ordered by name or ingredients at most locations.
In this guide, you’ll discover the best secret menu-style orders, hacks, and tips to upgrade your sandwich.
The Heavy Hitters: Top Jersey Mikes Secret Menu Ranked
While these aren’t on the overhead sign, our experienced grill masters and slicers know exactly how to build them when a “pro” customer makes the request.
1. The #99 – The Big Kahuna meets Chipotle
This is arguably the most famous secret menu item. It takes the #56 Big Kahuna (steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, and extra cheese) and adds a layer of our smoky Chipotle Mayo.
- Why it wins: It’s a flavor explosion that combines the maximum amount of toppings with a creamy, spicy finish.
2. The #44 – Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
A fan favorite for those who love a kick. This build uses our fresh-grilled chicken breast doused in Frank’s RedHot® sauce, topped with melted blue cheese crumbles (where available) or ranch dressing.
- Why it wins: It provides the perfect Buffalo wing experience in a fresh-baked sub roll.
3. The #12 – The Cancro Special
Named after a long-time family friend of the founder, this sub features All-Natural Roast Beef topped with Pepperoni and Provolone.
- Why it wins: It is a protein powerhouse that bridges the gap between our deli classics and Italian cured meats.
New to our hot subs? Start with the foundational [Jersey Mike’s Philly Cheese Steak] #17.
Best Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Items (Must-Try Orders)
Here are some popular secret menu-style combinations you can try:
| Secret Item | What’s Inside | Why People Love It |
| Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch | Chicken, bacon, chipotle mayo, ranch | Creamy + smoky flavor |
| Spicy Italian Deluxe | Italian meats + extra peppers + cheese | Bold and spicy |
| BBQ Chicken Sub | Chicken + BBQ sauce + onions | Sweet and smoky taste |
| Double Meat Philly | Steak with double meat + cheese | Extra filling |
| Ultimate Veggie Stack | All veggies + cheese + sauces | Fresh and healthy |
| Buffalo Ranch Chicken | Buffalo sauce + ranch + chicken | Spicy and creamy combo |
💡 These are not official items—you simply ask for the ingredients.
Prefer a zesty cold sub? Try our legendary #13 Jersey Mike’s Italian Sub ‘Mike’s Way’ first.
Secret “Mike’s Way” Hacks You Should Try
One of the easiest ways to upgrade your sub is by modifying Mike’s Way, a signature style at Jersey Mike’s Subs.
Popular Hacks:
- Mike’s Way + Mayo → adds creaminess
- No onions → for a milder taste
- Extra vinegar → more tangy flavor
- Add jalapeños → extra spice
👉 These small changes can completely change your sandwich.
Hidden Customization Options Most People Miss
Many customers don’t realize how flexible the menu is.
You can:
- Add extra meat or cheese
- Switch sauces (chipotle, ranch, etc.)
- Mix toppings from different subs
- Ask for lighter or heavier portions
👉 This is why Jersey Mike’s feels like it has a “secret menu.”
Viral Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Orders
Thanks to social media, some custom subs have become very popular.
These usually include:
- Extra sauces
- Double meat
- Unique flavor combinations
👉 People love sharing their “secret orders,” which is why this trend keeps growing.
How to Order Like a Pro
Because we are a “fresh-sliced” shop, ordering from the secret menu requires a little bit of deli etiquette to ensure you get exactly what you want.
- Be Specific with Ingredients: If a new team member doesn’t recognize the “number” (like the #99), simply describe the base sub and the additions. (e.g., “I’d like a #56 but can you add Chipotle Mayo?”)
- The “Mike’s Way” Rule: You can apply “Mike’s Way” (onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil, and spices) to any secret menu item. It’s highly recommended for the #12 Cancro Special!
- Timing is Everything: Secret menu items often involve extra steps on the grill or slicer. Ordering these during a slightly slower window ensures the crew can put that extra “A Sub Above” care into your custom build.
Learn how to order the #99 Giant online and earn maximum rewards with our Jersey Mike’s App guide.
Is the Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Worth It?
👍 Pros
- Unlimited customization
- Unique flavor combinations
- More satisfying meals
👎 Cons
- Not officially listed
- May cost extra for add-ons
- Depends on staff understanding
👉 Overall, it’s worth it if you enjoy trying new flavors and customizing your food.
FAQs About Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu
Does Jersey Mike’s Have a Secret Menu?
No, Jersey Mike’s does not have a formal or published secret menu.
However, many customers and employees have created unofficial combinations and custom orders that feel like secret items.
Can I order secret menu subs at any Jersey Mike’s?
While these items are not on the official menu board, any standard Jersey Mike’s location has the ingredients and training to prepare them. We recommend ordering by requesting the specific modifications (e.g., “A #56 with chipotle mayo”).
What is the most popular secret menu item?
Custom chicken and cheesesteak combinations with extra sauces are very popular.
Can you customize any sub?
Yes, most subs can be fully customized.
Is Mike’s Way part of the secret menu?
No, it’s a standard option—but many people customize it like a secret hack.
Does every Jersey Mike’s know the secret menu?
Most seasoned team members will know the #99 or the #12. However, since we have thousands of locations, it is always best to know the ingredients of your favorite secret sub just in case!
Is there an extra charge for secret menu items?
You will typically be charged for the base sub plus the cost of any “extra” toppings (like bacon, avocado, or extra cheese) that aren’t included in the standard build.
Can I order secret menu items on the app?
While you can’t search for “#99” in the app, you can easily create it by selecting a #56 and using the “Customize” button to add Chipotle Mayo.
Are secret menu items more expensive?
Generally, the price of a secret menu sub is the same as the base sub with any added toppings. A #99 is typically priced as a #56 Giant, while adding ranch or chipotle mayo may incur a nominal fee.
Final Thoughts
The Jersey Mike’s secret menu isn’t about hidden items—it’s about how you order.
At Jersey Mike’s Subs, you have the freedom to:
- Mix ingredients
- Add extra toppings
- Create your own perfect sub
👉 That’s what makes it exciting.
If you want a better sandwich experience, don’t just order from the menu—build your own version.
Ready to join the inner circle? Step up to the counter and try a secret menu masterpiece today. Your taste buds will thank you.
Explore our full menu and start customizing your order online!
