Jersey Mike’s Pepper Relish (What It Is, Ingredients, Taste & How to Order)
Jersey Mike’s pepper relish, officially known as our Hot Chopped Pepper Relish, is a signature zesty condiment made from a simple yet powerful blend of pickled red and green cherry peppers, vinegar, and salt.
The answer for fans looking to replicate that “Sub Above” heat at home is that we now sell our famed 16oz retail jars at most of our 2,500+ locations, as well as through select online retailers.
Whether you are adding a scoop to your #13 Original Italian or using it as a secret ingredient for your home-cooked meals, this relish provides a medium-heat “zing” that perfectly balances the rich fats of our premium meats and cheeses.
What Is Jersey Mike’s Pepper Relish?
Jersey Mike’s pepper relish is a chopped pepper topping made from a mix of peppers and seasonings.
👉 It is added to subs for:
- Extra flavor
- Slight heat
- Tangy kick
It is one of the signature toppings used at Jersey Mike’s, especially on subs ordered Mike’s Way.
Crave something hot? Check our guide on the [#17 Mike’s Famous Philly] to see how the relish cuts through the melted cheese.
What Is in Jersey Mike’s Pepper Relish Jar?
The exact recipe is not public, but it usually includes:
- Cherry peppers or red peppers
- Vinegar
- Oil
- Salt
- Spices
👉 It is finely chopped, which makes it easy to spread across the sandwich.
Taste and Flavor
The pepper relish has a unique flavor:
- Slightly spicy 🌶️
- Tangy (from vinegar)
- A little salty
- Mildly sweet
👉 Overall taste: balanced, bold, and flavorful—not too hot
Order a Sub in a Tub using our online tool and add this relish as a #10 Tuna Fish low-carb upgrade.
3 Best Ways to Use Pepper Relish in 2026
While it was born for our sub sandwiches, our fans have discovered ingenious ways to use the bottled retail jars at home:
- The “Philly Hybrid”: Add it to your #17 Mike’s Famous Philly or your home-made cheesesteaks. The vinegar in the relish cuts through the melted white American cheese beautifully.
- Deviled Eggs with a Kick: Mix a teaspoon of relish into your egg yolk filling for an instant gourmet upgrade to a classic party snack.
- Pizza Topping: Drizzle a little relish over a plain pepperoni pizza to add acidity and heat—a favorite trick for East Coast pizza lovers.
Redeeming points for a sub? Discover the best Jersey Mike’s sub to add this relish to.
Is Jersey Mike’s Pepper Relish Spicy?
The #1 question we get at the counter is: “Is the pepper relish too hot?”
- The “Taco Bell” Comparison: On a scale of spice, most fans compare our relish to a “Medium” salsa or a “Mild-to-Hot” taco sauce. It provides a noticeable “glow” in the back of the throat but won’t “melt your face off.”
- Consistency: Because we use natural cherry peppers, the heat can vary slightly by batch, but it is generally considered approachable for anyone who enjoys a jalapeño-level of spice.
- Pro Tip: If you’re nervous about the heat, ask for a “side cup” of relish. This allows you to dip your sub or add it sparingly until you find your perfect spice threshold.
Which Subs Use Pepper Relish?
At Jersey Mike’s Subs, pepper relish is commonly added to:
- Italian Sub
- Turkey Sub
- Tuna Sub
- Any sub ordered Mike’s Way
👉 You can add it to any sandwich you like.
How to Order Pepper Relish
Ordering is simple:
👉 Just say:
- “Add pepper relish”
- Or “Make it Mike’s Way”
👉 It will be included with your sub toppings.
New to our loyalty program? See how to [Jersey Mike’s Email Club Sign Up].
Is Pepper Relish Healthy?
👉 Yes, in moderation.
👍 Benefits:
- Low in calories
- Adds flavor without heavy sauces
- No cream or mayo
👎 Things to Consider:
- Contains sodium
- Slight oil content
👉 It’s a better alternative to heavy sauces like mayo.
Can You Buy Jersey Mike’s Pepper Relish?
👉 Usually, it is not sold separately in stores.
- It is mainly available inside the restaurant
- Some locations may allow special requests (not guaranteed)
Can You Make It at Home?
Yes, you can make a similar version.
Basic idea:
- Chop peppers finely
- Mix with vinegar, oil, and salt
- Let it sit for flavor
👉 While it won’t be exactly the same, you can get a similar taste.
Pepper Relish vs Other Toppings
| Topping | Flavor | Calories | Use |
| Pepper Relish | Tangy & spicy | Low | Flavor boost |
| Mayo | Creamy | High | Rich texture |
| Mustard | Sharp | Low | Tangy taste |
👉 Pepper relish is a light but powerful flavor option.
FAQs About Jersey Mikes Pepper Relish
What is Jersey Mike’s pepper relish made of?
It is made from chopped peppers, vinegar, oil, and spices.
Is pepper relish spicy?
It has mild to medium heat, not too strong.
Can I add pepper relish to any sub?
Yes, you can request it on any sandwich.
Can I buy it separately?
Usually no, it is not officially sold separately.
Can I buy Jersey Mike’s pepper relish in grocery stores?
While it is primarily sold at Jersey Mike’s locations, you can also find it at major retailers like Walmart or via our official app. Just ask a team member at the counter; most shops keep a stack of jars ready for retail sale!
Is the pepper relish gluten-free and vegan?
Yes! Our Hot Chopped Pepper Relish is naturally gluten-free and contains no animal products, making it a safe and delicious “spice boost” for almost any diet, including keto and vegan.
What is the price of a jar?
In 2026, a 16oz jar typically retails for around $5.95 to $7.50, depending on your location. It’s an affordable way to bring the “Sub Above” taste into your own kitchen.
Final Thoughts
The Jersey Mike’s pepper relish is one of the best ways to upgrade your sandwich.
At Jersey Mike’s Subs, it stands out because:
- It adds bold flavor
- It is not too spicy
- It is lighter than heavy sauces
👉 If you want to improve your sub without adding too many calories, this is a great choice.
Ready to add some heat to your life? Grab a jar during your next visit and experience the zesty tradition of Jersey Mike’s.
